Guest lounging by the pool at Grossinger's Resort in Liberty, New York, in 1977. © JT Vintage/Glasshouse/Newscom

Perspectives on the Conflagration

May 2, 2024

The war in Gaza has inspired powerful protest, unyielding contestation, and claims of genocide. In this issue of The Ideas Letter, we solicited three contributions that aim to bring new perspectives to some of the questions thrown up by the conflict.

Mark Mazower, Professor of History at Columbia University—a campus now seen as the ground zero for university protest- considers the conflation of antisemitism and anti-Zionism, with a particular focus on Franklin Foer’s recent essay in The Atlantic on the purported end of a liberal period of prosperity for Jewish Americans. The Nigerian writer and analyst Chris Ngwodo helps to interpret Israel-Palestine through the prism of African history and politics. And Daniel Levy, an erstwhile Israeli negotiator at Taba and Oslo, looks at the protests on U.S. college campuses and explains how the contradictory and dubious representations of the current Gaza war express underlying political struggles, including over antisemitism.

From our curated content we feature a superb explainer from Phenomenal World on the role of money and finance in the global financial system. This is followed by Tobi Haslett’s demolition of Thomas Chatterton Williams’ conceptions of the post-racial. Then, in a profile of economist Glenn Loury, we learn how Loury changed his mind more than once in his intellectual life, even calling a former draft of his memoir, “Changing My Mind.” Lastly, from The Baffler we showcase the concept of “Left melancholia,” Walter Benjamin’s plangent coinage, which looks mournfully at political defeats of the past.

This issue’s musical selection comes from the fine jazz drummer and bandleader Shelly Manne. In 1962 Manne recorded an LP featuring his arrangements of traditional and modern Jewish music, all played in the jazz idiom. Might it inspire hope for the improvisation of a different future for the Middle East? Here’s “Tzena” from Manne’s Steps to the Desert.

—Leonard Benardo, senior vice president at the Open Society Foundations